Respected Readers! Here I am going to present before you a very major lie. In fact, it is a very giant lie. At the outset, read the story narrated by him and, then, consider the references and evidence for it. Thereafter, you have to judge by yourself the magnitude of the lie mentioned by him. He writes in his book on Page No 91 that:

“Fatima, the daughter of Muhammad and wife of Ali, didn’t live any longer as she died as a martyr. Umar, the friend of Muhammad who became the second governor of Muslims, was responsible for her martyr. Umar came to the residence of Fatima with his companions and attacked her and set the gate on fire. Consequently, the gate fell on Fatima which led to the breaking down of the ribs of Fatima. This incident occurred a few days after the death of Muhammad and, eventually, Fatima died”.

Furthermore, he writes on Page No 93 that

“Fatima lived only for 90 days after the death of her father. When the Governor of Islam- Umar- and his companions set her residence on fire, she was standing behind the gate. As a consequence of pushing the gate by the enemies to storm into the house, she was stuck up between the wall which led to the breaking of her ribs. Besides, her son also died who was not born till that time of incident; who was named Mohsin from the pregnancy period itself.

He writes on Page No 84 that.

“When Umar went to the house of Ali, where Talha, Zubair and a complete group of migrants were present, Umar pushed and said: I swear by Allah! If you don’t offer your ‘Bait” (A pledge of loyalty) to me, I shall get all the members of your family set on fire. Having heard it, Zubair rushed out with his sword but he fell down and lost the grip of the sword from his hand. Subsequently, the men of Umar carried him away as a captive”

Explanation: To begin with, we shall historically take into consideration when did Prophet Muhammad (Peace & blessings be on him) pass away? When did Fatimatuzzahra (Raziyallahu Anha) pass away? When did the ‘Khilaafat’ (Governance) of Sayyadna Siddiqe Akbar (Raziyallahu Anhu) come into being? When did the ‘Khilaafat’ (Governance) of Sayyadna Hazrat Umar (Raziyallahu Anhu) come into being? When and how did Hazrat Fatima Zahra (Raziyallahu Anha) pass away? If one comes to know all these historical facts, a curtain of falsehood of the cursed Waseem Rizvi will automatically get lifted away.

It is mentioned in Tabqat Ibne Sa’ad, Volume Three, and Page No 30

“Prophet Muhammad (Peace & blessings be on him) passed away on 11 Hijri; and Sayyadna Siddiqe Akbar (Raziyallahu Anhu) became the ‘Khalifa’ (The Governor) on 11 Hijri”. It is mentioned in Tabqat Ibne Sa’ad, Volume Three, Page No 45 that he passed away on 22 Jamadil Ukhra, on 13 Hijri.

“On 13 Hijri, Hazrat Umar (Raziyallahu Anhu) became the Second Khalifa (Governor); and Hazrat Fatimatuzzahra (Raziyallahu Anha) passed away on 11 Hijri”.

It is mentioned in Tabqat Ibne Sa’ad, Volume Eight, Page No 47 that she proceeded to the life of immortality on 11 Hijri, at the age of around 29 years, on 3rd Ramadhan, on Tuesday night.

Now, let’s read about the death of Hazrat Fatima. It is mentioned in Tabqat Ibne Sa’ad, Volume Eight, Page No 46 that.

“Abu Raafe reports it from his father who narrates it from Sulami that Hazrat Fatimatuzzahra (Raziyallahu Anha) fell ill. Since Ali was out of station on the day when she passed away, she requested to get her to take a bath. So, Hazrat Salma poured water on her and she took a bath. She gave her the clothes which she wore. She requested me to lay down a cot which I did. Then, she turned towards the Qibla and said: Now, I’ll pass away. I have already taken a bath, so none should expose my body. Then, she passed away. I informed Ali. He performed the funeral ceremony without giving her a bath”.

Respected Readers! Now, consider the lies of the cursed Waseem Rizvi.

LIE NO 01

“If you don’t pledge on my hand, I’ll set all your family members on fire alive”.

Explanation: When Fatima Zahra passed away, it was the ruling of Hazrat Siddiqe Akbar (Raziyallahu Anhu) at that time. Consequently, how come it was possible that Hazrat Umar instructed Hazrat Ali (Raziyallahu Anhu) to take a pledge on his hand? Subsequent to the sad demise of Hazrat Fatima Zahra, the ruling of Hazrat Abu Bakar (Raziyallahu Anhu) continued for two years. Thus, this is a blatant lie of the cursed Waseem Rizvi.

LIE NO 02

“Muhammad’s friend, Umar, was involved in the martyr of Fatima”.

Explanation: You have just now studied the reference given in Tabqat Ibne Sa’ad that she died due to illness. Yet, the cursed Waseem Rizvi charges a false allegation on Hazrat Umar (Raziyallahu Anhu) that he was involved in the martyr of Hazrat Fatima Zahra. Hence, this blatant lie is also exposed and proved baseless.

LIE NO 03

“The door collapsed on Fatima which led to the breaking of her ribs and she succumbed to death”.

Explanation: The door collapsed, the ribs broke down and she succumbed to death. This narration is found neither in the History of Tabri nor in Tabqat Ibne Sa’ad nor in Sirat Ibne Hisham. Instead, Sirat Ibne Hisham mentions the illness as a cause of her death.

Kindly ponder over it! If Hazra Umar (Raziyallahu Anhu) inflicted the tyranny on her, wouldn’t Hazrat Ali (Raziyallahu Anhu) have retaliated against him? Was Hazrat Ali weaker than Hazrat Umar to retaliate? In fact, Hazrat Ali was so valiant and powerful that he lifted away the fort of Khaibar; his gallant was famous all across Arab and his title was ‘Shere Khuda’ (The lion of the Lord). It implies that the cursed Waseem Rizvi thinks Hazrat Ali (Raziyallahu Anhu) weak or coward. In fact, there didn’t occur any such instance at all. Therefore, such a false narration is brainchild of the cursed Waseem Rizvi himself.

LIE NO 04

“Her chest ribs broke down; and her son, who was not born till that time, also died who was named Mohsin well prior to his birth”.

Experience: This is an extreme degree of lie. Let’s think for a while, how come it was possible that a child was named while he was in the womb of the mother. Besides, how come it was possible to know that it was a son in the wormb? Furthermore, the cursed Waseem Rizvi hasn’t quoted any reference also to substantiate his statements.

Hence, this is nothing but a fabricated story which has nothing to do with the facts.

Let’s study the biography of the offspring of Fatima Zahra (Raziyallahu Anha) with the help of historical records. Qazi Sulaiman Salman Mansurpuri writes in his book “RAHMATUL-LIL-AALAMIN” (The mercy for both worlds), Volum Two, Page No 111 that Imam Hasan, Imam Husain, Umme Kulsum and Jainab were born off the sacred body of Hazrat Sayyadna Fatima Zahra (Raziyallahu Anha). He further writes that some writers have included the names of Mohsin and Ruqayyah also as the children of Sayyadatun Nisaal Aalamin (The leader of the women of the world). However, the historians don’t write these names as the children of Hazrat Fatima Zahra (Raziyallahu Anha). It is also believed that Mohsin and Ruqayyah died in their childhood and, therefore, their life sketches are not available in the books of history.

Neither Tarikhe Tabri nor Sirat Ibne Hisham nor Tabqat Ibne Sa’ad nor any other historical record records that Mohsin died in the foetus itself and he was named Mohsin before his birth.

It appears that the cursed Waseem Rizvi has sworn to insert the lies on each and every instance of his book as he has piled up the instances of lies in writing the biography of Hazrat Fatima (Raziyallahu Anha) also.